·9 min read
How Country Conditions Can Influence Commercial Contract Performance in Political Risk Disputes
How country conditions can affect commercial contract performance in political risk disputes: regulation, policy, timing, hindsight and other contributing factors.
Commercial contracts involving international operations can be affected by political, regulatory, economic, and institutional developments in the countries where the parties operate. In some disputes, understanding these country conditions may help place an alleged contractual difficulty within its wider context.
Country conditions do not necessarily determine whether a party has performed its contractual obligations or whether a particular legal defence applies. Those questions depend on the contract, applicable law, evidence, and the issues before the relevant decision-maker.
Where political or country-specific developments form part of the factual background, political risk analysis may help explain the environment in which contractual performance occurred.
For an overview of the firm's areas of work, see Political Risk Expert services.
What Are Country Conditions?
Country conditions are the political, institutional, regulatory, economic, and social circumstances relevant to a particular jurisdiction and period.
Depending on the dispute, these may include:
- Changes in government or public administration
- Regulatory or policy developments
- Political instability
- Changes in public institutions
- Restrictions affecting international transactions
- Economic conditions
- Changes in relations between government authorities and particular industries
- Political developments affecting business operations
The relevance of any particular condition depends on the facts and timeframe of the dispute.
A country condition should not automatically be treated as the cause of contractual non-performance. Its relevance may need to be assessed against the contract, the parties' circumstances, and other factors affecting performance.
Why Country Conditions May Matter to Contract Performance
International contracts may depend on circumstances outside the immediate control of either contracting party.
For example, performance may involve:
- Obtaining government approvals
- Importing or exporting goods
- Accessing local infrastructure
- Making or receiving cross-border payments
- Operating under sector-specific regulation
- Obtaining licences or permits
- Employing personnel in a particular jurisdiction
- Working with local public authorities
A change in the political or regulatory environment may affect one or more of these conditions.
That does not necessarily establish that the country development caused a contractual failure. Instead, it may provide part of the factual context that needs to be considered.
Political Risk and Commercial Contract Performance
Political risk can arise from developments associated with governments, political institutions, public policy, or the broader political environment.
Commercial contract performance can also be affected by ordinary business factors such as:
- Changes in demand
- Supplier difficulties
- Financing problems
- Operational decisions
- Market competition
- Pricing conditions
- Management decisions
In a dispute, these factors may exist simultaneously.
A political risk analysis may therefore consider political developments alongside the wider commercial environment rather than treating a political event as the only possible explanation for a performance issue.
For further context, see the commercial arbitration risk page.
How Political Developments May Affect Contractual Performance
Regulatory Changes
A change in regulation may alter the conditions under which a business operates.
For example, a new licensing requirement or change in sector regulation may affect the timing or practical requirements associated with a project.
The relevant analysis may include:
- When the regulation was introduced
- When it became effective
- Whether transitional arrangements applied
- How the change affected the relevant sector
- What information was available when the contract was performed
The existence of a regulatory change does not, by itself, establish whether a contractual obligation was breached or whether any legal exception applies.
Changes in Government Policy
Changes in government policy can affect industries differently.
A change in policy may influence the operating environment for companies involved in infrastructure, energy, natural resources, financial services, telecommunications, or other regulated sectors.
A political risk expert may examine the broader policy context, including how and when the policy developed and whether the change represented a significant departure from the previous environment.
Political Instability
Political instability can create uncertainty for businesses operating in a particular country.
Depending on the circumstances, relevant developments may include changes in government, political unrest, institutional disruption, or significant changes in public administration.
The practical effect on a contract will depend on the circumstances. A period of political instability does not necessarily prevent contractual performance, and its relevance may differ between industries, locations, and contractual obligations.
Restrictions on Cross-Border Activity
International contracts may involve the movement of goods, services, capital, or personnel across borders.
Political or governmental developments may affect these activities through changes to:
- Import or export requirements
- Foreign exchange arrangements
- Payment restrictions
- Border controls
- Licensing requirements
- Customs procedures
- Sector-specific restrictions
Where such developments are relevant to a dispute, establishing the chronology and practical context may be important.
The Importance of Timing
Country conditions can change significantly over the life of a commercial contract.
A political environment that existed when a contract was negotiated may differ from the conditions that existed when performance became difficult.
For this reason, an assessment may consider the relevant timeline, including:
- The date of contract formation
- The political and regulatory environment at that time
- Subsequent political or policy developments
- The date on which a particular difficulty arose
- The information available to the parties at relevant points
- Later developments that may have changed the country environment
This can help distinguish between conditions that existed when the parties entered into the contract and developments that emerged later.
Avoiding Hindsight When Assessing Country Conditions
Later developments can affect how earlier political conditions are perceived.
For example, a government policy that eventually resulted in significant restrictions may appear more predictable when viewed after the restrictions were introduced. The information available before the change may have presented a more uncertain picture.
Political risk analysis may therefore distinguish between:
- Information available at the relevant time
- Political developments that were already underway
- Risks that were publicly identified
- Developments that became apparent only later
This historical approach can be relevant where a dispute requires an assessment of the political environment at a particular date.
Distinguishing Political Factors From Contractual Issues
A political risk expert may provide analysis of country and political conditions, but that analysis does not necessarily answer the contractual or legal questions arising from a dispute.
For example, an expert may be able to examine:
- The political context surrounding a regulatory change
- The chronology of government policy
- The development of political instability
- Country-specific institutional conditions
- The effect of a political development on the operating environment
Other questions may fall outside the scope of political risk expertise, including:
- Whether a contractual obligation was breached
- How a contractual term should be interpreted
- Whether a legal defence is available
- Whether a party is legally liable
- The appropriate legal remedy
Those questions depend on the applicable legal framework and the decision-making process in the relevant dispute.
Assessing Multiple Contributing Factors
A contractual performance problem may have more than one contributing factor.
Consider an international project where performance slows following a change in government policy. At the same time, the project may face higher financing costs, supply-chain difficulties, or reduced market demand.
A political risk analysis may consider the political development as part of that wider environment. It should not necessarily assume that the political development explains the entire commercial outcome.
Relevant questions may include:
- What changed politically or institutionally?
- When did the change occur?
- What contractual performance issue followed?
- Were other difficulties already present?
- Did other businesses or projects experience similar conditions?
- How did the relevant industry respond?
- What information was available at the time?
The answers will depend on the evidence available in the particular matter.
Sources Used to Examine Country Conditions
A political risk assessment may draw on a range of sources, depending on the subject and timeframe.
Potential sources include:
- Government publications
- Legislation and regulatory materials
- Official statements
- Parliamentary records
- Institutional publications
- Contemporary reporting
- Industry sources
- Economic information
- Historical records
- Other relevant publicly available material
Sources may need to be assessed in light of their date, purpose, reliability, and relevance to the particular issue.
Contemporary material can be especially useful when examining what political conditions or policy developments looked like at the time. Later commentary may provide additional context but should not automatically be treated as evidence of what was known earlier.
The Role of Political Risk Expert Evidence
Where political and country conditions are relevant to a dispute, a political risk expert may examine the political, governmental, institutional, and country-specific circumstances within their area of expertise.
Depending on the instructions, this may involve analysis of:
- Political developments affecting a relevant industry
- Government policy and regulatory context
- Institutional changes
- Country-specific operating conditions
- Historical political developments
- The chronology of relevant events
The scope of an expert's work will depend on the questions requiring specialist evidence.
For an overview of the firm's relevant dispute work, see the practice areas.
Questions to Consider When Reviewing Country Conditions
When country conditions are relevant to commercial contract performance, several questions may help structure the analysis.
What Country Development Is Relevant?
Identify the political, regulatory, institutional, or economic development said to have affected performance.
When Did It Occur?
Establish when the development began, when it became publicly known, and when it may have affected the relevant business or project.
What Was the Operating Environment?
Consider the wider political and commercial conditions affecting the relevant sector and jurisdiction.
What Other Factors Were Present?
Consider whether operational, financial, market, supply, or management factors may also have affected performance.
What Information Was Available at the Time?
Distinguish contemporary information from later developments to reduce the risk of relying on hindsight.
What Is the Scope of the Expert Question?
Identify which issues require political or country analysis and which questions concern contractual interpretation, legal responsibility, valuation, or other specialist disciplines.
Conclusion
Country conditions can form an important part of the factual background to some international commercial contract disputes, particularly where performance depends on regulatory, political, institutional, or cross-border conditions.
A careful political risk analysis may examine the relevant country environment, chronology, government policy, institutional developments, and available contemporary evidence. It may also consider how political factors interacted with wider commercial and operational conditions.
The existence of a political or country risk does not by itself establish contractual non-performance, causation, liability, or entitlement to a particular remedy. Those issues depend on the facts, contract, applicable law, evidence, and questions before the relevant decision-maker.
Where specialist political or country analysis is required, the appropriate scope of expert evidence will depend on the circumstances of the dispute and the particular questions within the expert's area of expertise.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about political risk and country conditions in commercial disputes and is not legal, financial, investment, or professional advice. The relevance of particular political or country factors will depend on the facts and circumstances of each case.
